PROLOTHERAPY AN ALTERNATIVE TO NECK SURGERY
Ross Hauser, M.D.
I recently saw a patient who had suffered for at least ten years
with
neck pain
and was told it was time to consider surgery. The
doctor (surgeon) wanted to do a multi-level fusion, but the patient
wanted to look at alternatives including
Prolotherapy.
After six Prolotherapy sessions, the patient's neck stiffness and
pain were gone. He stopped taking anti-inflammatories.
Another patient this week came in with a
herniated disc as evidenced
by
MRI scan and
referral
pain down her arm. Her physician wanted to
send her to a surgeon, but she decided to look at alternatives
first.
She was seen for eight sessions of Prolotherapy, after which all of
her pain was relieved.
Why Seek an Alternative?
The results of neck surgery for completely eliminating neck pain
have been poor. Neck surgery, more often than not, “changes” the
pain, but does not eliminate it. Long term studies have also shown
that neck arthritis often progresses at a faster rate after neck
surgeries such as laminectomies or discectomies then if the person
didn't have the surgery at all. For this and many other reasons,
people are seeking alternatives.
To answer the question posed above, let's consider why someone even
gets a surgical recommendation. The overwhelming reason is that they
have unremittant neck pain.
Often they have failed anti-inflammatories,
cortisone shots,
chiropractic manipulation, and physical therapy and go for a
surgical consultation “as a last resort”. Typically their x-rays or
MRI's show a lot of degeneration, sometimes
degenerated discs,
facets, or
herniated
discs.
The secret to successful treatment is actually in the x-rays and
MRI's. You see, the overgrowth of bone that shows up as “arthritis”
is actually the body's healing system response to make those areas
more stable.
Fusion operations are recommended to further stabilize these areas.
The problem with fusions are that they don't allow any movement in
the fused areas, so the areas above and below the fusion have to
compensate and move more. Those areas degenerate quickly and the end
result for the patient is that the pain “changed”.
I believe a better option is one that can stabilize the areas of
pain without surgery – namely Prolotherapy. The areas of pain are
“unstable” because of
ligament laxity/stretching or weakness. The
muscles over these segments then go into spasm to stabilize these
areas. This is why the person often gets muscle spasms that aren't
permanently relieved by physical therapy, massage, or
steroid injections.
These treatments don't stimulate ligament repair. The best treatment
for this is Prolotherapy. Prolotherapy is an
injection technique
that stimulates the body to repair ligaments. Once the ligaments are
tight, strong, and repaired, the muscle spasms stop because the area
is stable.